China Change

Home » Uncategorized » Yes China! – Book Review

Yes China! – Book Review

Clark Nielsen came to China with no training and no clue how to be an English teacher, Yes China! An English Teacher’s Love-Hate Relationship with a Foreign Country ($13.45 paperback, $5.99 Kindle) is the enjoyable record of what happened next. The majority of the book focuses on his experiences in a variety of classroom settings and his failure to understand how to properly lesson plan.

Clark’s first foray into China was with a largely Mormon summer teaching program, which leads to interesting reflections from Clark on his former faith and how his decision to leave the church has changed his life (non-China related personal content makes up about 20-30% of the book). It’s also an account of him struggling to control a class full of primary students who seem to understand only the most basic commands. From the primary classes I have sat in on, it sounds like a realistic picture of the chaos that can ensue in such an environment. He finds the same is true at the middle school level.

Clark’s recounting of daily classroom scenes should serve new English teachers well, especially those still considering what level they would be interested in teaching (these sections make up about 40-50% of the book). For me and my wife, who worked at a particularly crazy school in Chengdu, we found Clark’s passages of internal rage cathartic. There are however a few instances where he crosses the line from humorous to dangerous. While I have dreamed of gingerly tossing a student’s book out the window, I have never actually acted on it.

The remainder of the book takes a wide angle view of daily life as an expat in China (30-40%). His descriptions of bus rides, overnight trains, and cafeteria food are again humorous and fairly accurate. I appreciated that he tried to describe scenes as they were, but at times he gets caught up in hyperbole to the point that it can be hard to tell what was actually happening.  As another reviewer noted though, there is a fair amount of “bathroom humor,” and he seems to relish the opportunity to describe in full detail some of the worst bathrooms he’s seen.

While the book overall is a fun and easy read, it is not without its flaws. First and foremost, it is quite poorly organized. One might assume with a memoir that it would start at the beginning of the experience and then progress linearly to when he leaves China. Clark however skips forward and backward in time without much notification. Half way through he also reveals that much of the content came from his blog, which isn’t surprising given his informal writing style. He would have greatly benefited from an editor to help him sort out the wheat from the chaff.

Given these problems I would still recommend it to people considering teaching English in China, or current teachers who are looking for someone to commiserate with. It can be easily finished in a couple of sittings, and is worth the few hours it takes to complete it.  Yes China! however is not going to teach China hands anything they don’t already know about the culture or history.

If you are interested in learning more practical information about being an English teacher in China, check out my guide to teaching in the Middle Kingdom.


5 Comments

  1. Lorin Yochim says:

    Looks like its self-published, Tom, which probably means self-edited. Are you offering your skills on the open market?

    • Tom says:

      It is indeed self-published, but there are very few grammar problems (which isn’t always the case with self-published books). I think its more of the overall review process that would have benefited him. I have helped a few other bloggers with editing, but I’m not on the market for anything this size 🙂

  2. […] original post here: Yes China! – Book Review | Seeing Red in China This entry was posted in Books and tagged book-review, chengdu, china, clark, clark-nielsen, […]

  3. […] few months ago I reviewed Yes China! by Neil Clark, and when a friend asked me to review another book about teaching English in China I was a little […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s